WG Warding Poll

[Mojo]

I am curious to see what WG members voted for. 

We can compare this with the OSRS wide results on Wednesday.

[Glaucon24]

yes

[Jason]

I voted yes

[WG Logout]

Yes to warding/ no to prayer armor/no to lamp/no to skilling rings/no to rune pouches

[Dr Yes]

literally another grindy useless skill.

 

[WG Wessoxx]

no !!!

[Mojo]

given the number of no, votes I've added a second question.

[Mask]

Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! to all questions

[Glaucon24]

Yes to all questions, except for Pado set, skilling rings, and minigame questions. I voted no for those.

[Glaucon24]

For people who voted no to question 1 and yes to question 2, exactly what features would a new skill need to have? In what ways does warding fail to have those features? What alternative skill might you propose instead of warding that suits OSRS? In what ways is this alternate proposal superior to the warding proposal?

 

 

 

Edited July 20, 2019 by WG Glaucon

[Mojo]

Here is reddit's exit poll currently showing 71%, looks to be very close

 

 

[Anthony]

Completes a gap in the skilling market so I'm all for it

[WG Jester]

Voted yes. I understand arguments for and against warding and I still think its all around going to be very good for the game.

 

if you don't want a grind you're playing the wrong game kiddos

[1 gf]

Yes and no to those shitty skilling rings. Maybe the devs will devote their time to PVP updates if warding finally passes 

[Lait Choco]

I voted no as it is an extremely shitty skill and to this point still pretty unbalanced and still got some seious concern about certain aspects of the skill.(imbues, XP/H, ..) Also I don't want another bankstanding skill that you just can buy and get 99 overnight. Not to mention the 41 google document is written by someone who doesn't understand skilling fully...

Also Reddit likes it so it is an logical choice to vote againt what Reddit wants toprevent the game from becoming another RS3.

 

If this skill passes I'll quit, I've coped enough shit because the devs pander to a single community where the average users fails to secure a fucking Runescape account.

 

 

 

7 hours ago, WG Glaucon said:

For people who voted no to question 1 and yes to question 2, exactly what features would a new skill need to have? In what ways does warding fail to have those features? What alternative skill might you propose instead of warding that suits OSRS? In what ways is this alternate proposal superior to the warding proposal?

No fucking buyable bankstanding

Sailing

 

[ccnut]

Voted yes

[TheSandFoxx]

I voted yes to all questions. I thought that this new content could be cool. And the devs seem 100% committed to working with the community to make warding the best skill and best fit for OSRS possible.

[Doc Cassidy]

voted no and will vote no on almost any conceivable proposed skill. Did anyone who voted yes play rs2 before rs3? this "might be cool" attitude is why we are all playing osrs and not rs3. 

 

[Flocked_Up]

Yes to everything because more magic armour means more variety in the wildy.

[Corbula]

I voted yes for all of it except for the skilling rings. Wasn't happy with what they looked like...

 

Quite interested in the elemental tomes!

[Doc Cassidy]

59 minutes ago, Flocked_Up said:

Yes to everything because more magic armour means more variety in the wildy.

this can be accomplished with adding more armor w/o new skill; plus, magic buff can be done with new spells or items. why introduce a new skill? 

[Mojo]

Ignoring the strange “skip” answers, Reddit’s poll is on 76% yes. Looks like this will be close. 

[hunkybum]

no to skilling rings yes to everything else

[Zutheris]

Voted yes to the skill. No to the skilling rings, pouches, lamps, and pado armor.

[WG Jester]

Yeah I think most people are in agreement that pados set, the skilling rings and certain rune pouch options are things that shouldn’t pass.