Back to Topic Index
Well fine.
By WG_Keanu on 27/09/2010
I'm putting my video of the WG vs 'The' war back on public. That's the one with the TS audio.
This is following Jayson's video of the BK war which also has audio.
Debate tiem. I was originally told to take it off for two reasons:
1: It gave away how we call.
ALL CLANS CALL THE SAME WAY.
It's either a RSN or a level, and a location method such as the direction where they are, what they're wearing, what prayers they're using, etc. The only thing we do differently is we don't usually get a fall-in after a pile, we just go straight onto the next pile once one is done. Sometimes a fall-in helps, sometimes an instant transition helps. It doesn't really matter if the other clan knows, because whether they see a member go down OR a fall in, they know incoming pile. Who we pile can't really change their RSN or level mid-war. If they run south, we call them running south. If they pray melee and then mage instead, we deck em. If they take off what they're wearing, we deck em.
2: It gives clans the ability to potentially kill our callers.
WHAT.
How the eff barbecue do they know who our callers are? They have no idea what Justin or Kyle or anyone sounds like on TS. If they do, our fall-in order changes every time, so all it does is tell them our ranks. WE HAVE A RUNEHEAD ML AND FORUMS WHICH SAY THAT ANYWAY. They can't hear our TS during the war in any case. If a caller gets piled, they say "someone take over" - name a clan that doesn't do that.
My video in no way compromises the clan's privacy. If anyone disagrees, discuss. For now, my vid stays public.
This is following Jayson's video of the BK war which also has audio.
Debate tiem. I was originally told to take it off for two reasons:
1: It gave away how we call.
ALL CLANS CALL THE SAME WAY.
It's either a RSN or a level, and a location method such as the direction where they are, what they're wearing, what prayers they're using, etc. The only thing we do differently is we don't usually get a fall-in after a pile, we just go straight onto the next pile once one is done. Sometimes a fall-in helps, sometimes an instant transition helps. It doesn't really matter if the other clan knows, because whether they see a member go down OR a fall in, they know incoming pile. Who we pile can't really change their RSN or level mid-war. If they run south, we call them running south. If they pray melee and then mage instead, we deck em. If they take off what they're wearing, we deck em.
2: It gives clans the ability to potentially kill our callers.
WHAT.
How the eff barbecue do they know who our callers are? They have no idea what Justin or Kyle or anyone sounds like on TS. If they do, our fall-in order changes every time, so all it does is tell them our ranks. WE HAVE A RUNEHEAD ML AND FORUMS WHICH SAY THAT ANYWAY. They can't hear our TS during the war in any case. If a caller gets piled, they say "someone take over" - name a clan that doesn't do that.
My video in no way compromises the clan's privacy. If anyone disagrees, discuss. For now, my vid stays public.
By rachellove9 on 27/09/2010
Take it off the public til we have a chance to review and discuss it in staff. If you have a real problem with giving us a little more time then pm me. I'm sure if you were asked to remove it before there was a reason.
You are breaking a WG rule too. You are not to go against leadership. Just take it off the public for now. Council will need to review and decide.
You are breaking a WG rule too. You are not to go against leadership. Just take it off the public for now. Council will need to review and decide.
By Randy on 27/09/2010
Having our Teamspeak play in your video isn't really helping the vid quality anyway.
I don't see the big deal.
I don't see the big deal.
By Armybuilder1 on 27/09/2010
i think tbh . Who cares? do you honestly listen to a video to wahts being said? Unless therse a commentry.
By Kung Man149 on 27/09/2010
Keanu, I think it's best it remain private for the simple fact that they can tell who's calling by carefully listening to calling styles and in game movements.
I'm against it as well but it seems to be the best course of action.
I'm against it as well but it seems to be the best course of action.
By Elyxiatic on 27/09/2010
| QUOTE: Kung Man149 @ September 28, 2010 08:19 am) |
| Keanu, I think it's best it remain private for the simple fact that they can tell who's calling by carefully listening to calling styles and in game movements. |
This man is wise ^
By George on 27/09/2010
Yes but you can blatantly see who our callers are via the ML.
We rarely have callers at wars who aren't raid leaders/warlords on that ML, except when we're under-staffed or on raids.
I've watched the whole video. I've been through it more than once with a fine toothpick.
I don't think it compromises our security in any way.
We rarely have callers at wars who aren't raid leaders/warlords on that ML, except when we're under-staffed or on raids.
I've watched the whole video. I've been through it more than once with a fine toothpick.
I don't think it compromises our security in any way.
By Quikdrawjoe on 27/09/2010
Who ever is calling on TS tends to be leading fall ins and such.
By Jayson on 28/09/2010
I dont really see any big deal with it.
SURPRISE, THE PERSON LEADING THE FALL IN IS CALLING
:o:o:O:O:o:o:o
And we have many members who have leadign experience anyway, if they wanted to pick off our fall in leaders, they would.
SURPRISE, THE PERSON LEADING THE FALL IN IS CALLING
:o:o:O:O:o:o:oAnd we have many members who have leadign experience anyway, if they wanted to pick off our fall in leaders, they would.
Back to Topic Index