An interesting idea

Not sure how things would change though, i mean to say that we're already recruiting well, no? And combat level increasing is obviously a big thing atm what with Pro Silentium. I dont see how things like those would change to become any better than they already are.
The ones like you said like 'Not having a member kicked from the clan for a month' and 'Pulling the most people to a war' are valid alternatives, but the whole 'Not having a member kicked from the clan' could possibly encourage the council not to kick someone who in fact needs to/deserves to be kicked :S And the 'Pulling as many people to a war as possible' thing is also a big thing being worked on by WG staff atm what with the CWPL and mandatory sign-ups etc :\ I don't see how things would be changed to improve when already the steps are being taken :S Could you elaborate on your idea? <3
~Mugger84