Back to Topic Index
MOTM June and any promo's?
By JC on 02/07/2008
I havent been very active for the latter half of this month so I dont really have any idea who would be suitable for Member of the month.
Promotion wise:
Guardian -> Higher
Spanthrax
This guy has been here for a while, and though he has had a hickup or two lately with him and Crucio he is a nice member normally. Probably deserved this last month.
Knight War6
Probably too soon, but just look at his XP gains through PS> That to me shows just how dedicated seiggy is to WG.
Higher -> Elite
Mager123789
Mager was suggested a couple of months ago for this promotion, however his attitude sucked at the time. He is still as active as ever and from what I have seen his attitude has been much better than it was previously.
Chip54321
Chip is fairly active, and always seems very friendly to me. Note he has attended 9 events in the last 2 weeks according to weekly event attendance.
Any other idea's? objections? MOTM?
By Winddancir on 02/07/2008
MOTM - Pbplayer9 / Vince
He's always there in IRC, active, and generally a great person to interact with.
By Buzzard1985 on 02/07/2008
QUOTE (Winddancir @ July 01, 2008 08:32 pm) |
MOTM - Pbplayer9 / Vince He's always there in IRC, active, and generally a great person to interact with. |
+1
I think the promo's you posted Evil are good.
By Indivi2you on 02/07/2008
Promo's seem valid. Chip really deserves it.
MoTM = Vince is a sure candidate. Possibly Chip instead of promo.
He's helped with Quests, getting items and such. Is at almost every war/event. And gives out robe sets.
By General199 on 02/07/2008
I beg to differ with Spanthrax. You even stated he had a hiccup but that was a rather big HICCUP. I am against him getting a promotion this month. I think we will need to wait a month more to see whether or not he should be promoted.
Mager I think is a good choice. He is always on the positive and showing up to every event he can. In my eyes I see him to get a promotion.
Chip is a good idea to. Been very active and friendly in irc.
MOTM - I would think Sonix. He gained a tremendous amount in Agility for this month.
Knight War6 I think is a yes. He showed tremendous dedication with the amount of experience he got in attack.
By Buzzard1985 on 02/07/2008
I still say Spanthrax gets a promo, he's been doing good since Crucio was kicked/left. I know he's been working for a promotion too.
By Back to Own on 02/07/2008
IMO, possible candidates:
MOTM:
Chip - He's been an excellent team player, helping promote important things that win us wars. Hes supplied quest sets for infinite run, and has handed out free hybriding sets at wars. Hes also an excellent hybrid and a very helpful person in general.
Vince is a good candidate, but chip has done a ton for the clan
Promotions
Mager123789 - Very active, excellent hybrid.
Kiwi - Very IRC active and active. I've talked to him personally, and hes taken up hybriding even though he finds it very difficult for him. He continues to try very hard even with set backs.
By Robertw56 on 02/07/2008
I agree with your promotions except for one...Spanthrax, I swear he's bi-polar dude. I wouldn't be happy if he got the promo.
Vince for MOTM
By Anatcrafter on 02/07/2008
Definately Chip for elite. I'm a little edgy about Spanthrax but like you said he is a nice guy despite one mess up. I like Vince for motm too.
By Abmanju on 02/07/2008
Yep, all of those promotions are definitely deserved, even spanthrax, I was going to promote him, but then he did something back then, can't remember, he is an excellent member, he tries very hard to please everyone.
MoTm, we should decide this on who got the most exp on Pro Silentium to be honest.
~Abs
By Zlatan83 on 02/07/2008
Pretty much agree with your promotions althoght I'd like to see Spanthax warn level go down before promotion.
By Gusmighster on 02/07/2008
Agreed with all, and yea, Vince for motm.
By General199 on 02/07/2008
I still do not think that Spanthrax should get a promotion. What he did was not promotion worthy. Not to mention it was not even that long ago. It was in the same month that it happened. If you promote him it just goes to show that we are easy to get around things like he did.
By DZ on 02/07/2008
Spanthrax still deserves it IMO. He was a really great member before the whole Crucio thing and lately there hasn't been anything bad coming from him. He's been a regular guardian for a very long time and should have been promoted the last time, but along came Crucio.
By Cameronm123 on 02/07/2008
Chip for elite
By General199 on 02/07/2008
QUOTE (Darkzero101 @ July 02, 2008 10:20 am) |
Spanthrax still deserves it IMO. He was a really great member before the whole Crucio thing and lately there hasn't been anything bad coming from him. He's been a regular guardian for a very long time and should have been promoted the last time, but along came Crucio. |
Crucio happened before last promotion's and this promotion's. His actions to crucio and the time from then where he has been good now does not suffice in my eyes to give him a promotion.
By Troll84 on 02/07/2008
I agree with most of what's been said promotion-wise, except Spanthrax. His few 'hiccups' have had quite a negative effect on the clan in recent weeks. From his performance this month he (IMO) does not by any means deserve any form of promotion :S All other's I agree 100% to though

~Mugger84
By Zlatan83 on 02/07/2008
QUOTE |
Kiwi - Very IRC active and active. I've talked to him personally, and hes taken up hybriding even though he finds it very difficult for him. He continues to try very hard even with set backs |
You know, it was him that started the "Martyr" /power abusing thingy.
By JC on 02/07/2008
QUOTE (General199 @ July 03, 2008 03:57 am) |
QUOTE (Darkzero101 @ July 02, 2008 10:20 am) | Spanthrax still deserves it IMO. He was a really great member before the whole Crucio thing and lately there hasn't been anything bad coming from him. He's been a regular guardian for a very long time and should have been promoted the last time, but along came Crucio. |
Crucio happened before last promotion's and this promotion's. His actions to crucio and the time from then where he has been good now does not suffice in my eyes to give him a promotion.
|
Should we hold his actions in this case against him? The fact was Crucio caused 90% of the abuse he got (NO he did not deserve it, but yes he was he cause of it) and as a result I dont think that spanthrax should be penalised as a result.
In the end, ignoring the recent problems with Crucio (and don't forget that much longer serving, and higher ranked people abused Crucio.... span was just the worst) spanthrax is a good member with good activity etc.
By General199 on 03/07/2008
Yes he has good activity and everything but I think he needs to wait atleast one more month. Just to prove himself.
By George on 03/07/2008
Yes definately chip for elite!
Vince for MotM possibly, he's active, always helpful and good-natured.
Do not promote Sonixpber, he's barerly come to any events recently.
By General199 on 03/07/2008
George none of us said Sonix for promotion. I said for MoTM.
By Indivi2you on 03/07/2008
I thought Sonixpber for MotM, but like george said, he isn't very active. I think Chip is ideal for MotM, or atleast Elite guard. He really deserves it. Vince had a promo last month, so either he gets MotM or nothing?
By JC on 06/07/2008
Final Promotions:
Guardian -> Higher
Spanthrax
Knight War6
Higher -> Elite
Chip54321
Kiwi011
Mager123789
MOTM:
Pbplayer9
Back to Topic Index