Did you guys not listen to us?

By General199 on 06/07/2008

There where quite a few of us that said no to promoting spanthrax! He did not deserve to be promoted.

QUOTE

General199: I beg to differ with Spanthrax. You even stated he had a hiccup but that was a rather big HICCUP. I am against him getting a promotion this month. I think we will need to wait a month more to see whether or not he should be promoted.

QUOTE

Robert: I agree with your promotions except for one...Spanthrax, I swear he's bi-polar dude. I wouldn't be happy if he got the promo.

QUOTE

Zlatan: Pretty much agree with your promotions althoght I'd like to see Spanthax warn level go down before promotion.

QUOTE

Mugger: I agree with most of what's been said promotion-wise, except Spanthrax. His few 'hiccups' have had quite a negative effect on the clan in recent weeks. From his performance this month he (IMO) does not by any means deserve any form of promotion :S All other's I agree 100% to though.

That is 4 of us directly quoted from the topic.

By Robertw56 on 06/07/2008

This was an epic fail promoting him sorry. He'll think he can get away with anything now.

By Abmanju on 06/07/2008

We listened, however we decided that Spanthrax has made up through it with Video Guides, screenshot guides, general helping of other members, I know he's helped me a hell of a lot, he always tries to lower his temper down and has always said sorry. He is always nice, and deserves the promotion.

And yes, ONLY Four of you disagreed.
The people who agreed/were ok with the promotion of spanthrax:

-Abmanju
-Theevildead2
-Buzzard1985
-Indivi2you
-Back To Own (Didn't say anything about Spanthrax, so I assume ok from him)
-Anatcrafter (Said that spanthrax made one mess up, he's a nice guy otherwise)
-Gusmighster
-Darkzero101
-Cameronm123 (Didn't say anything towards Spanthrax)
-Gorgemaster (Didn't say anything towards Spanthrax)

There are SIX Definite people said Spanthrax getting a promotion was ok.
There are TEN people who seem to be ok with Spanthrax getting a promotion (No objections).

Also, the bottom line is that Council makes the decisions, it used to be just Council doing the promotions, Lvl 3 doesn't make the Decisions but they do have some say in the promotions, since Council is only 3 or 4 people, we need more people to have an influence on the promotions, that's why we look towards Lvl 3.

And if I'm wrong, please correct me, but there are 3 Council members who have given a Yes to Spanthrax getting a promotion.

~Abs

By General199 on 06/07/2008

I dont think some guides and shit make up for the shit he did. HE TREATED SOMEONE AS IF THEY WERE SHIT. That should not be tolerated and it should definitely be punished. How do we know that he hasnt learned his lesson? For all we know he is thinking he got off with just a warn level.

Bad decision on councils part in my opinion.

By Abmanju on 06/07/2008

Now you're being unreasonable, "Some guides & shit"; You're trying to make the work he did smaller by portraying it in those words. He realised the Warns, and therefore he did a lot of good for the clan, now that we've given him a promotion, it would mean he would do more for the clan to reach the next stage.

You learn from your mistakes, you don't do them again, it's natural, I'm sure he won't repeat what he did.

I'm locking this since there's no need for it. Council's decision is final, if it's "Bad", then that's your opinion =)

~Abs

Back to Topic Index