Back to Topic Index
Sign-ups precaution
By Ragingwealth on 09/09/2008
PLEASE note: I'm not trying to accuse anyone, this is just a pre-caution because it's better safe than sorry.
I'd like to suggest that our sign ups (For the +3 day preps fights, in other words most official wars) become PRIVATE AND ONLY ACCESSABLE BY RAID LEADERS+
There is a reason for this, anyone can intro to WG and within 2 days, he'll become a trial guardian, where that person can access our war forums and may leak some warring information to the other clan. I'm not refering to our trial guardians, I'm refering to the spies in this case.
Think about it, if they manage to see our sign ups then they can find out the perfect targets for piling before we meet them in CW, they also may adjust their tactics accordingly.
Again, please note: I'm not saying this because this happened and/or someone leaked war info, I'm saying this just as a precaution for wars in the future (Mainly RAWs and the officials)
Short prep fights (1-2 days) should have public sign ups since they really wouldn't matter much
There is no harm at all in linking to a private thread/pm so people can sign up instead of posting on the war thread. It'll keep these info safe and in the same time keep people anxious and excited about our turn-out.
Thoughts, opinions, etc? Post away
I'd like to suggest that our sign ups (For the +3 day preps fights, in other words most official wars) become PRIVATE AND ONLY ACCESSABLE BY RAID LEADERS+
There is a reason for this, anyone can intro to WG and within 2 days, he'll become a trial guardian, where that person can access our war forums and may leak some warring information to the other clan. I'm not refering to our trial guardians, I'm refering to the spies in this case.
Think about it, if they manage to see our sign ups then they can find out the perfect targets for piling before we meet them in CW, they also may adjust their tactics accordingly.
Again, please note: I'm not saying this because this happened and/or someone leaked war info, I'm saying this just as a precaution for wars in the future (Mainly RAWs and the officials)
Short prep fights (1-2 days) should have public sign ups since they really wouldn't matter much
There is no harm at all in linking to a private thread/pm so people can sign up instead of posting on the war thread. It'll keep these info safe and in the same time keep people anxious and excited about our turn-out.
Thoughts, opinions, etc? Post away
By Quikdrawjoe on 09/09/2008
Or you could move it to Level 1 which would require full guardian.
By Geoff_Bland on 09/09/2008
It's not like clans can crash wars, seeing sign up lists wont make *that* much a differance but for very important wars I guess this is ok 
EDIT: When the new PvP comes out we will probably have to think things over.
EDIT: When the new PvP comes out we will probably have to think things over.
By Ragingwealth on 09/09/2008
| QUOTE (Quikdrawjoe @ September 09, 2008 06:58 pm) |
| Or you could move it to Level 1 which would require full guardian. |
Could work but it isnt very secure, anyone can use a secondary account and wait through our trial process, especially if its a clan we fight quite often
P.S. If that is also the case, how will our real trial's sign up for wars?
Edit:
@ Geoff
It's not bout crashing, its about having a pile order memorized that could help control the fight. Think about it, if we had 5 people who are average tanks and 1 person who is an awesome tank, the other clan spied so they piled the 5 people before the tanker, which caused us to lose.
If they didnt know, there is a chance that they'd pile the awesome tank, which could secure us a win.
By Mager123789 on 09/09/2008
you made a good point here..
but idk how the council/raid leader will be able to keep with all these pms then..
but idk how the council/raid leader will be able to keep with all these pms then..
By Zlatan83 on 09/09/2008
How are people supposed to sign up for wars, specially trials if they cant see the forum ? 
By Ragingwealth on 09/09/2008
| QUOTE (Zlatan83 @ September 09, 2008 07:28 pm) |
| How are people supposed to sign up for wars, specially trials if they cant see the forum ? |
In the forum's permissions, I -think- you can give posting but not viewing rights, so you link people to the reply to the topic page and they can sign up
I'm not sure if this works on our forums, but I know they do work on Phpbb, might ask robbie
Back to Topic Index