Call of Duty 4 vs. Halo 3

I stole this from RSC, but it quite possibly is the hardest question mankind has ever faced.

Halo 3 or CoD4? Which is better?

CoD4 because i like the gameplay and how fast it can get sometimes.

Halo 3 is still a good game, but i very rarely play it nowadays

Both are excellent games, but which is better? Call of Duty.

I LOVE the class system and the customization options it provides, plus, it seems a little more "real" than Halo.

I've played Halo a little bit, and I watched a guy playing CoD for awhile today in one of the campus computer labs. It looks wicked. I didn't like Halo much.

I've only played Cod4 but I don't see how Halo can be better

Cod4

CoD: World at War

ur gona be abit suprised but i do find call of duty 4 better then halo3 after i misjudged it i got into the maps and ye its not bad it owns halo3 anyday

CoD4 simple as. And matt, its not possible.

You missed out an option.

"I Play both CoD4 and Halo 3 and find them both to be a different style of FPS and thus comparing them is like comparing cheese and PC Speakers."

I enjoy both equally

I might play more Halo 3, but that is because I live with a flatmate and CoD4 does not allow splitscreen on Live.

It depends on preference, whether one wants to play a more tactical almost one hit kill game with current weapons, or a futuristic Sci-fi game with shields and futuristic weapons.

The actual gametypes in the games are different too, I don't see any oddball in CoD4, but I also don't see any Headquarters in Halo 3.

CoD4

Halo 3 feels like Halo 2.5


and CoD has a replayability factor to it considering how addicting leveling up in that game is

Cod4 gets really boring sometimes. There is allot of bullshit things that happen in it. I'd still prefer playing it to Halo, but Halo is a really good game.

I like comparing cheese and pc speakers, why not?

Both are freaking awesome but CoD4

Both are amazing games in all respects. Here's my opinion of both:

Halo is more for when you just wanna go have some fun blowing up aliens and using laser guns and all that, it's much more fast paced and not quite as tactical as CoD4. The ranking systems are all great and really show your true skill and place you where you need to be in order to have fair games.

CoD4 is more tactical and competitive, as well as realistic. It's amazing for when you really wanna go out and prove yourself in a fight. It has tons of different customizable settings for you to be truly unique in a fight, rather than racing to see who can get the good guns first, and many different gametypes that you can choose at will.

My final verdict: Halo = less realistic but easier and more fun, CoD4 = more tactical and lets you do what you're best at.

I've played both, and I find them both equally fun, and can easily play either at any time of the day.

The only problem I've had with CoD4 was the repetitive nature of the ranking system. Sure you get a nice new symbol each prestige, but other than that why bother going through it again and again only to reach a ceiling at level 10? If you could prestige forever at 10th prestige and just redo it then it might be more fun, but personally I got bored lol. It's an amazing game, but I just lost interest.

Same thing happened to Halo back when CoD4 came out, but they are really supporting the game and making it better all the time with new maps and gametypes, as well as events within matchmaking every week. Can't wait for these Mythic maps to come out.

I still say I can play them both equally though. If I were stranded on an island, I'd pick Halo just for it's campaign replayability.

Halo is more running and gunning based from what I've seen/played. The easiest way to kill someone is by melee'ing them because it takes quite a few shots to kill someone. This does make it quite fun yet I prefer the tactfulness of CoD.

Halo reminds me of a hyperactive kid who ate too many sweets and CoD4 reminds me of a Buddhist monk.

I have both and COD4 is def better.

Unfortunately Halo 3(well actually, Halo 2 and 3, considering 1 was actually a great game) is the most over rated game in existence so COD4 obviously is my choice.

I love both, but CoD4 for me.

COD4 definatly, the whole pick your own class and perks and such totally kill Halo3.

It even have a Halo3 like gameplay, where you have to pick up weapons and such, you start out with a pissy gun.